This is a long-term post that will collect my ideas on church music. I will start it small, just to get it going.
1. Keep in mind that church music is not a performance for an audience, even an audience of God. The congregation is there too, and they’re supposed to be worshipping. If you want a concert for God, do it with no congregation present.
This idea has lots of implications. One is that there should not be instrumental interludes, preludes, or postludes, during which the congregation waits nervously. Another is that beauty is not the main goal (if it were, you’d expel the congregation, because they cough, sing badly, etc.)
2. If there is a solo, let the congregation chip in at the last verse.
3. Don’t have undignified children songs with gestures, etc., except for children. It is degrading for adults, insulting the Dignity of Man.
4. Overheads slide person is most important person.
5. People should be able to hear each other singing.
6. Don’t jazz up arrangements just for the sake of putting personal
imprint on it. Old arrangements are old for a reason– they’re good.
7. Clapping is good for kids and illiterates. Make sure they can participate somehow.
8. Have strong male voices leading.
9. Not too many verses of any one hymn.
10. Explain hymns in advance.